The percentage
Obie Benson of the Four Tops played the song on guitar, and Marvin Gaye played piano. “The first time he sang it, I was playing guitar and he was playing piano, and it was so beautiful,” Benson said. He had already tried to give it away. Now he made Gaye an offer. “I finally put it to him like this: I’ll give you a percentage of the tune if you sing it, but if you do it on anybody else, you can’t have none of it.” Gaye’s wife, Anna, was listening. “His wife told him, ‘Marvin, this is a perfect song for you.’ I’ll love Anna forever for making him see the truth of that.”
The song had started in 1969, on the road. The Four Tops’ tour reached San Francisco while police and protesters were fighting in Berkeley over a disused lot called People’s Park. Accounts of how he saw it differ: from the tour bus, stuck in traffic, or on television. Benson himself said only that he saw it. “They had the Haight-Ashbury then,” he said, “all the kids up there with the long hair and everything. The police was beatin’ on them, but they weren’t bothering anybody. I saw this, and started wondering what the fuck was going on.” He began a song about it with Al Cleveland, a lyricist who often worked with Smokey Robinson.
The rest of the Four Tops would not record it. “My partners told me it was a protest song. I said no, man, it’s a love song, about love and understanding. I’m not protesting, I want to know what’s going on.” On a British tour he tried a folk singer he met at a television studio, picked up her guitar in her dressing room and played it to her. “She seemed interested, but somehow we got separated and I never got to finish presenting it to her,” he said, and he could not remember her name. The writer Ben Edmonds identified her as Joan Baez.
Other accounts have the song reaching Gaye differently: after a round of golf, with Gaye at first wanting it for the Originals, a Motown group he was producing. The Detroit Lions running back Mel Farr, one of Gaye’s friends, said he told him to keep it. “No, Marvin. That’s you, man! You got to sing this!” In every version Gaye took the song, rewrote parts of it and took a share of the writing. Benson did not mind. “He added lyrics, and he added some spice to the melody,” he said. “We measured him for the suit and he tailored the hell out of it.”
Read the whole story, and every issue.
Long reads are for members: one story from the scene, told at length. About 17 minutes of reading. Still to come: “Three years”, “The factory”, “June 1970”, “Nothing more”, “The acetate”, “A month”, “Sunset and Argyle”.
Start your 7-day free trialAlready a member? Sign in